So this has happened to me before. I’m enjoying a book, reading along, and then BAM! Genre change! Everything stops making sense.
I think authors do this to add a certain shock value, but I’m honestly not sure how to feel about it. It’s like with every book, I have a certain comfort zone that’s created by my expectations of what that book is, and when it changes so drastically like this, the entire book become unbelievable. Let me give an example.
I read this book several years ago. (And it was freakishly hard to find on goodreads for this post. Do you have any idea how many books are titled “Thicker than Water?”) WARNING: Complete spoilers ahead.
It’s basically about a girl who- to escape the troubles of her teen life- goes to nightclubs where she discovers vampires doing weird vampire things. She spends the entire book trying to blend in with the vampires and get evidence about who they are, until at the end she approaches one to ask him to change her into a vampire. Except surprise! He isn’t a vampire. In fact, no one is. Vampires don’t exist. Weirdos that go drinking other people’s blood in nightclubs, however, do exist. The whole thing left a bitter taste in my mouth.
This happens with videogames, too.
This was my very first horror game when I was a kid. That was okay, though, because it was a zombie game, and I wasn’t afraid of zombies. Except, halfway through I find out it’s not a zombie game. It’s an alien game! And I was terrified of aliens! The first level that the zombies started to get weird alien mutations I was playing with my sister and I was so badly scared and surprised that I cried. Except we’d gotten so far and I didn’t want to re-do all the progress we’d made, so I played with my eyes half closed until the aliens came on and then it was my sister’s turn. We never did win that game. No way I’m going back to it, though. Pff. Aliens.
This even happens with movies!
Is anyone surprised that the genre-swapping movie in question was written by M. Night Shadymellon? Spoilers ahead! (Kinda)
People live in an old-timey witchcrafty village, kept inside by fear of monsters. One lady strays out of the village at the very end and the audience finds out that it’s not, in fact, set in old times, it’s in the 21st century.. and no one ever noticed this village-trapped-in-time because they were in a nature preserve.. And I guess no one ever goes to those.
So, overall, I think this genre-change deal exists to create a major shock value in the reader/player/watcher, but in the end, all it does for me is make the entire thing seem pointless and unbelievable. Except for in the case of Siren, in which it just made the whole thing f&^*ing terrifying.
Have you ever come across a piece of media like this? What do you think when something suddenly changes genres? Do you like the shock, or does it ruin the whole thing? I’m interested to know your thoughts!
This was really a interesting post. Why do you consider the first one a genre change? It sounds like it was a plot twist (which may or may not have been done well).
Thank you! I consider it a genre change because the entire book was played out like a fantasy, like in Twilight where you just KNOW they’re vampires. It was such a shock that it wasn’t a fantasy world at the very, very end. It couldn’t really be considered fantasy because there was nothing truly “fantasy” in it- just assumptions of fantastical things.
UGH, this annoys me so much. It happened with The Name of the Star by Maureen Johnson for me – I didn’t expect it to be paranormal and given that it’s my least favourite genre, it completely ruined it for me 😦
Isn’t it crazy when that happens? I know I read the genre I’m in the mood for (like everyone, I’d imagine) so when an author doesn’t make a book what it’s promised to be, they’re going to foster annoyance at that book. That’s a little how I felt about The Girl with All the Gifts.
I have read books like this!! AND I HATE IT. gah. I feel…betrayed? Like if I pick up a book because of a specific genre, then I want it to be that genre. If it’s upfront about it in the first, then it’s okay. But I hate the sneak-genre-change-attack. Like in Because You’ll Never Meet Me it was all a contemporary and heartfelt and then — BOOM — it’s sci-fi. That didn’t work for me at all and I ended up hating the book. *le sigh*
I remember your review on that! And Betrayed is exactly the word for it! It was exactly how I felt writing my review for The Girl with All the Gifts. You just can’t do something like that to a reader!